docs: flesh out Multi-Agent plan shipping log + Team Workbench forward plan

The Multi-Agent Workbench shipped end-to-end (commits 1771063df through
7c89eb625). This commit turns the plan doc into a proper history + post-
mortem and captures the deferred Team-Workbench as its own forward plan
so the architectural breadcrumbs don't rot.

docs/plans/multi-agent-workbench.md:
- Status bumped to  Shipped; every phase checkbox flipped.
- Open-questions section rewritten with the decisions that were
  actually made (name-unique via store write-time check, per-source
  system principalIds, policy fully migrated, scene binding default-
  empty with smart suggestion).
- New "Shipping-Historie" table mapping each phase to its commit, the
  number of files touched, and the test outcome.
- New "Lessons Learnt + Follow-Up Ideen" with:
  * What went better than expected (L3 Actor cutover, getOrCreate
    instead of unique index, displayName caching)
  * Thin spots worth revisiting (avatar not on Actor, missing token
    counter for budget, no missions list on agent detail, no
    drag-reassign, scene binding doesn't drive filters yet)
  * Five deferred follow-up projects (team features, agent memory
    self-update, agent-to-agent messaging, meta-planner, per-agent
    encryption domains)

docs/plans/team-workbench.md (NEW):
- Full forward-looking plan for the deferred Team-Workbench.
- Two use-cases (human multi-user vs multi-agent sharing team
  context) with the observation that they share the same infra.
- Decision candidates table (still open — meant as T0 RFC fodder,
  not baked in).
- Architecture sketch with data-model deltas over the current
  single-user shape.
- Encryption subsection dedicated to the hardest problems: team-key
  wrapping per member (reuses Mission-Grant pattern), member-removal
  rotation (lazy vs eager), Zero-Knowledge-mode incompatibility.
- T0..T6 phasing (~7 weeks for a clean first-pass).
- Section "Wie Multi-Agent dafür den Weg geebnet hat" enumerating
  the four invariants the shipped Phase 0-7 deliberately preserved
  to make this plan cheap when it lands.

docs/plans/README.md (NEW):
- Index doc with the AI/Workbench roadmap as an ASCII flow so future
  contributors can locate themselves in the sequence without reading
  three 400-line plans first.

docs/future/AI_AGENTS_IDEAS.md:
- Header marks Point 1 (encrypted tables) as shipped via the Mission
  Grant plan; points 2-8 stay relevant. Cross-link to all three plan
  docs so this stays the go-to backlog.

services/mana-ai/CLAUDE.md:
- Design-context header expanded to link to all four related docs
  (arch §20-22, both shipped plans, forward team plan, ideas backlog).

No code changes.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Till JS 2026-04-15 22:17:04 +02:00
parent 6da317d071
commit e8077a44b4
6 changed files with 554 additions and 54 deletions

51
docs/plans/README.md Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,51 @@
# Plans
Design + rollout plans, grouped by topic. Plans are long-form docs with
baked-in decisions, phasing, open questions, and (when shipped) a
history section with commit refs.
## AI / Workbench roadmap
The Mana AI Workbench has evolved in three successive planned waves —
each one laying foundations the next one relies on:
```
User hat einen Companion (v0 — shipped before these docs)
AI Missions + Proposals + Policy + Revert
Mission Key-Grants ← ai-mission-key-grant.md ✅
(encrypted inputs decryptable by the server runner)
Multi-Agent Workbench ← multi-agent-workbench.md ✅
(named agents, per-agent policy/memory/budget,
identity-aware Actor, scene→agent lens)
Team Workbench ← team-workbench.md 📝 (not started)
(multi-user + shared AI context,
admin lens on team members)
```
| Plan | Status | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| [`ai-mission-key-grant.md`](./ai-mission-key-grant.md) | ✅ Shipped | Per-mission RSA-wrapped key grant so `mana-ai` can decrypt allowlisted encrypted records when user opts in. |
| [`multi-agent-workbench.md`](./multi-agent-workbench.md) | ✅ Shipped | Identity-aware Actor + named AI agents owning missions + per-agent policy + scene lens. |
| [`team-workbench.md`](./team-workbench.md) | 📝 Forward-looking | TeamSpace with membership, team-encrypted records, admin lens on team members. Reuses Actor.principalId + key-wrapping patterns from the two above. |
Cross-references:
- Architecture narrative: [`docs/architecture/COMPANION_BRAIN_ARCHITECTURE.md`](../architecture/COMPANION_BRAIN_ARCHITECTURE.md) §20 (AI Workbench base), §21 (Mission Grants), §22 (Multi-Agent)
- Non-plan ideas backlog: [`docs/future/AI_AGENTS_IDEAS.md`](../future/AI_AGENTS_IDEAS.md)
- Service-internal notes: [`services/mana-ai/CLAUDE.md`](../../services/mana-ai/CLAUDE.md)
- Webapp-internal notes: [`apps/mana/CLAUDE.md`](../../apps/mana/CLAUDE.md) → "AI Workbench" section
## Other plans
| Plan | Topic |
|---|---|
| [`mail-module-plan.md`](./mail-module-plan.md) | Mail module — IMAP/SMTP integration |
| [`news-research-module.md`](./news-research-module.md) | News + research pipeline |